Skip to Main Content
Mama Mia's Italian Cuisine logo topMama Mia's Italian Cuisine logo scroll
  • (414)-475-0400
  • info@mamamiasmilwaukee.com
  • 8533 West Greenfield Avenue , West Allis
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • ORDER
  • EVENTS
  • CATERING
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • HOURS
  • Facebook pageYelp page
Mama Mia's Italian Cuisine logo topMama Mia's Italian Cuisine logo scroll
  • Facebook pageYelp page
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • ORDER
  • EVENTS
  • CATERING
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • HOURS

Our Menu

Main MenuKid's MenuParty Pans

CARRY-OUT and DINE-IN: MON TUE & THUR: 11am - 9 pm | FRI & SAT: 11am - 10 pm | SUNDAY: 11am - 8 pm

Appetizers

Our Famous Homemade Garlic Bread photo

Our Famous Homemade Garlic Bread

$3.99
$4.99
Made with 100% real Butter |

Mozzarella Marinara

$9.95
5 Large Mozzarella sticks hand-breaded in our Kitchen and served with Marinara sauce

Eggplant Strips

$9.95
Hand-breaded in our Kitchen and served with Marinara sauce

Breaded Mushrooms

$9.95
Hand-breaded in our Kitchen and served with Marinara sauce

Breaded Zucchini Strips

$9.95
Served with Ranch dressing

Combination Platter

$11.95
Mozz Sticks, Mushrooms & Zucchini, served with Marinara sauce

Chicken Tenderloin Strips

$9.95
BBQ, Honey Mustard, Ranch or Honey on request

Jalapeño Cream-Cheese Poppers

$9.95
served with Marinara sauce or homemade Raspberry sauce

Minestrone Soup

$3.99/Cup
$5.99/Bowl
$10.50/Quart
Homemade in our Kitchen

Salads

House Salad is served with iceberg & Romaine lettuce, Mozzarella cheese cubes, Pepperoni, tomatoes, and pepperoncini | Salad Dressings: Our House (Oil & Vinegar) | Homemade Ranch | Peppery Parmesan | French | 1000 Island | Bleu Cheese | Honey Mustard | Extra Sides (mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, pepperoncini) ea. $1.00 Caesar Salad is made with Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing and homemade Garlic Bread croutons

Dinner House photo

Dinner House

$3.99
Medium House photo

Medium House

$9.75
Serves 1-2 people, includes 1 garlic bread
Large House photo

Large House

$15.25
Serves up to 4 people, includes 2 garlic bread
Caesar Salad - side photo

Caesar Salad - side

$4.99
Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese, homemade croutons and Caesar dressing. Add a baked Chicken breast +$4.95 / anchovies +$2.50
Caesar Salad Entree photo

Caesar Salad Entree

$10.95
Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese, homemade croutons and Caesar dressing. Comes with one Garlic Bread. Comparable in size to our House Salad - Medium. Add a baked Chicken breast +$4.95 / anchovies +$2.50

Sandwiches

Mushrooms-Onion-Green Peppers-Marinara Sauce (free) | Mozzarella cheese - $1.00 | Add waffle fries - $1.95

Grilled Mozzarella Cheese on Garlic Bread photo

Grilled Mozzarella Cheese on Garlic Bread

$10.50
Our twist on an old favorite using grated mozzarella cheese on our homemade Garlic Bread and served with a cup of our house-made Meat Sauce for dipping. (You can request Marinara instead)

Meatballs on Garlic Bread

$12.50
Our hand rolled meatballs served in meatsauce on our Garlic Bread which has been sliced in half.

Sausage on Garlic Bread

$12.50
We start with a hand-formed sausage patty, bake it, and serve it up on our homemade Garlic Bread.

Following sandwiches served on toasted Gonnella bun (Similar to a Hoagie bun)

Italian Beef photo

Italian Beef

$12.25
Thinly shaved beef dipped in our special au jus and served on a Gonnella bun/similar to a hoagie bun. Giardiniera sauce on the side.

Sicilian Chicken

$11.50
Marinated, baked chicken breast, served on a Gonnella roll with marinara sauce and Mozzarella cheese

Chicken Parmesan

$12.50
Hand-breaded chicken breast that is deep fried and then topped with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Served on a Gonnella roll/similar to a Hoagie roll.

Pasta

Lunch 11am to 3pm / Dinner : 3pm to close | All entrees include one Garlic Bread

Pasta with Meatsauce or Marinara Sauce:

Spaghetti photo

Spaghetti

$9.95/Lunch
$12.95/Dinner
Lunch/Dinner $9.95/$12.95

Mostaccioli

$9.95/Lunch
$12.95/Dinner
Lunch/Dinner $9.95/$12.95

Ravioli

$9.95/Lunch
$12.95/Dinner
Beef or cheese, or combo | Lunch/Dinner $9.95/$12.95
Fettucini Alfredo photo

Fettucini Alfredo

$11.50/Lunch
$14.50/Dinner
Made from scratch Lunch/Dinner $11.50 /14.50 | w/ sliced chicken breast +$4.95

Build Your Own Pizza

(9 inch Mini available at lunch-time only) Made with Our Famous Thin-Crust - Small* 11" - Large 14" - Mini 8" (lunch only)|

Mozzarella Cheese Pizza

$8.25/+
Mini $8.25 | Small $12.45 | Large $16.75

Regular Toppings

$1.50/+
Mushrooms | Onions | Black Olives | Green Olives | Green Peppers | Diced Tomatoes | Italian Spices blend |Sliced Jalepeno | Mini $1.50 | Small $2.25 | Large $2.75

Premium Toppings

$1.75/+
Sausage | Pepperoni | Ground Beef | Anchovies | Pineapple | Canadian Bacon | Chopped Garlic | Pepperoncini | Extra cheese | Mini $1.75 | Small $2.50 | Large $3.50

"E.B.A."

$14.25/Mini
$21.45/Small
$27.95/Large
Everything But Anchovies” | $14.25 | $21.45 | $27.95

"Garden"

$10.75/Mini
$16.45/Small
$20.95/Large
Mushrooms, onions, black olives, green peppers & diced tomatoes | $10.75 | $16.45 | $20.95

"Hawaiian"

$11.75/Mini
$14.25/Small
$19.10/Large
Canadian-style bacon & pineapple | $11.75 | $14.25 | $19.10

"Sicilian"

$10.20/MIni
$15.45/Small
$20.55/Large
Diced tomatoes, onions, fresh garlic, Italian spice blend & a splash of extra-virgin olive oil | $10.20 | $15.45 | $20.55

Gluten-Free 10” Crust ($2.50 extra)

Topping prices correlate to small pizza

Lunch Entrees

Lunch 11am to 3pm / Dinner : 3pm to close | All entrees include one Garlic Bread

Lasagna photo

Lasagna

$10.25
Our famous lasagna features layers of pasta, meat sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

Spinach Lasagna

$10.25
A special twist on an old favorite features pasta sheets layered with marinara sauce, ricotta cheese, asiago cheeses and spinach. Very good, but quite different from our regular Lasagna.
Baked Pasta w/ Mozzarella Cheese photo

Baked Pasta w/ Mozzarella Cheese

$9.95
Penne/mostaccioli noodles with meatsauce, topped with Mozzarella cheese and oven baked.

Manicotti

$9.95
Ricotta cheese baked in pasta rolls with Marinara sauce, topped with Mozzarella cheese, then oven baked.

Chicken Parmesan

$13.95
The lunch portion features 1 chicken breast, hand-breaded and then deep-fried, topped with Marinara sauce, Mozzarella and Parmesean cheeses, served on a bed of pasta.

Eggplant Parmesan

$11.95

Lunch Specials

Monday: Mini Pizza

$13.50
Up to 3 toppings and includes one Garlic Bread

Dinner Specials

Monday: Lasagna

(1 garlic bread with each Las.) Buy 1, Get the 2nd at half price

Monday: Family Night Pizza Special

$34.25
Large pizza with up to 3 toppings, 2 Garlic Breads & pitcher of soda or 1/2 carafe House wine + $7 | Dine in Only

Tuesday: All You Can Eat pasta

$13.50
Spaghetti or Penne / Marinara or Meat sauce. Served with one Garlic Bread | Dine in Only

Thursday: Pizza

Buy 1 and get the 2nd at half price

Friday:

Baked Fish Lemon Butter

$14.75
3 pieces of baked cod served with melted butter and lemon slices. | Side of coleslaw, a small side of Pasta with Marinara or MeatSauce, and one Garlic Bread

Baked Fish Sicilian

$14.75
3 pieces of baked cod topped with Marinara and Mozzarella cheese. | Side of cole slaw, small Pasta with either Marinara or MeatSauce, and one Garlic Bread.
Fish Fry photo

Fish Fry

$14.75
Over a half pound of beer-battered cod paired with flat spiral fries, coleslaw, tartar sauce & one Garlic Bread

Dinner Entrees

Dinner served 3pm to close | All Entrees include one Garlic Bread

Lasagna photo

Lasagna

$14.75
One of our Signature Items. Layers of pasta sheets, our homemade MeatSauce, and Mozzarella cheese.
Spinach Lasagna photo

Spinach Lasagna

$14.75
A special twist on an old favorite features pasta sheets layered with Marinara sauce , ricotta cheese, asiago cheeses and spinach. Very good, but quite different from our regular Lasagna

Baked Pasta w/ Mozzarella Cheese

$14.25

Manicotti

$14.25
Chicken Parmesan (2 chicken breasts) photo

Chicken Parmesan (2 chicken breasts)

$19.95
The dinner portion features 2 chicken breasts, hand-breaded and then deep-fried, topped with marinara sauce, mozzarella and parmesan cheeses, served on a bed of pasta.

Eggplant Parmesan

$16.50

Sides

Pasta (2/3 Pint) with Sauce

$4.50
side of Spaghetti or Penne/Mostaccioli with Meat Sauce or Marinara

Meatball (1) Hand-Rolled

$2.95
Our meatballs are made in-house, by hand, using our Garlic Bread crumbs, cheese, spices and then oven-baked. The pre-baked weight is 4 oz

Italian Sausage Link or Pattty

$4.25

Chicken Breast

$4.95
Marinated and oven-baked chicken breast

Anchovies

$2.50

French Fries

$1.95
Waffle-cut

Desserts

Tiramisu photo

Tiramisu

$6.95

Ultimate Chocolate Cake

$7.95
multiple layers of chocolate cake and chocolate frosting

Oreo Cheesecake

$7.95
Cannoli photo

Cannoli

$3.50

Ice Cream Scoop

$3.50
Spumoni or Vanilla

Limoncello Cheesecake

$6.95
A refreshing, Italian-inspired cheesecake made with sweet ricotta and cream cheese with luscious limoncello flavors and shortbread topping, Served with homemade Raspberry sauce

Sauces To Go

SIZE REFERENCES: Cup = 8oz | Pint = 16 oz (two Cups) | Quart = 32 oz (two Pints)

Cup MeatSauce

$2.99
8 ounces of our signature Homemade MeatSauce

Cup Marinara

$1.99
8 ounces of Marinara sauce

Cup Alfredo Sauce

$3.50
8 ounces of our homemade Alfredo sauce

Cup Melted Butter

$2.50

Pint MeatSauce

$5.99
16 ounces of our signature Homemade MeatSauce

Pint Marinara

$3.99
16 ounces of Marinara sauce

Pint Alfredo Sauce

$6.95
16 ounces of homemade Alfredo sauce

Pint Salad Dressing

$4.25

Pint Melted Butter

$5.99

Quart MeatSauce

$11.99
32 ounces of our signature Homemade Meatsauce

Quart Marinara

$7.99
32 ounces of Marinara sauce

Quart Alfredo Sauce

$13.75

Quart Salad Dressing

$8.50

Soup

We have Homemade Minestrone every day. Made with ditalini noodles, beef, kidney beans, carrots, celery. A classic Italian soup

Minestrone

$3.99/Cup
$5.99/Bowl
$10.50/Quart
Homemade in our Kitchen

MISCELLANEOUS ITEMS

Miscellaneous Items

Plate

9" foam plate

Napkin

Parmesan Packet

Red Pepper Flakes packet

Individual Silverware Pack

fork, knife, spoon set up for individual orders

Kid's Menu Dishes

Pasta dishes made with your choice of: Homemade Meat Sauce | Marinara Sauce

Mostaccioli (Penne) with Garlic Bread

$6.50
with MeatSauce or Marinara

Ravioli (Beef or Cheese) with Garlic Bread

$6.50
with Marinara or MeatSauce

Spaghetti with Garlic Bread

$6.50
with Marinara or MeatSauce

Fettuccini Alfredo with Garlic Bread

$6.50

Fettucini Alfredo w/ 1/2 Chicken Breast

$8.95
Fettucini Alfredo with 1/2 baked chicken breast with Garlic Bread

Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Mozzarella Cheese

$6.50
Add Fries for $1.50

Chicken Fingers with Waffle-Cut Fries

$6.50

Party Pans can be ordered in small and large sizes. Garlic Bread served with pasta dishes; no Garlic Bread is served with Salad choices. Party pans do not come with serving utensils {Spatula, Tongs, Serving Spoon}. But they can be added for a small price. (We do not include the cost of utensils into party pans because many customers do not need them.)

Party Pan Options

Large: Serves 16 - 20, includes 10 Garlic Bread | Small: Serves 8 - 10, includes 6 Garlic Bread

Lasagna

$84.95/small
$159.95/large
Layers of noodles and MeatSauce topped with oven-melted Mozzarella cheese. This is a Mama Mia signature dish!

Spinach Lasagna

$84.95/small
$159.95/large
A special twist on a favorite! Pasta sheets layered with Marinara sauce, Ricotta and Asiago cheese and Spinach

Ravioli

$84.95/small
$135.95/large
Beef, Cheese or Combination of both. Can be served with Homemade MeatSauce or Marinara.

Fettucini Alfredo

$84.95/small
$159.95/large
Homemade Fettucini made in house with Butter, Cream, Garlic, Cheese. (No flour is used when making the Alfredo sauce)

Spaghetti

$74.95/small
$129.95/large
Spaghetti served with either Marinara or MeatSauce

Mostacciolli

$74.95/small
$129.95/large
Penne / Mostaccioli pasta served with Homemade MeatSauce or Marinara

Chicken Parmesan

$119.95/small
$229.95/large
Includes a bed of pasta ~ Large (20 chicken breasts) | Small (10 chicken breasts)

Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo

$104.95/small
$189.95/large
Served with oven-baked diced chicken breasts: 4 for the small and 8 for the large.

Baked Pasta

$79.95/Small
$144.95/Large
Mostaccioli / penne noodles with Marinara or Homemade MeatSauce and topped with Mozzarella cheese and oven baked.

Italian Salad

$29.95/small
$55.95/large
Does NOT include garlic bread ~ Large (serves 30 people) | Small (serves 15 people). Served with a mix of Romaine /Iceberg. Diced mozzarella and tomatoes, Pepperoni, and Pepperoncini. Comes with House Italian salad dressing. Other salad dressing available on request.

Garlic Bread

$34.99
10-Pack of Garlic Bread. You save by buying in quantity.

Spatula

$1.50
Spatula for serving Lasagna

Tongs

$1.50
Tongs for serving Garlic Bread, Salad

Serving Spoon Large

$1.50
Good for serving Ravioli, Fettucini, etc

Individual Utensil Pack

$0.20
wrapped packet of knife/fork/spoon for party pan quantities
  • Order
  • Catering
  • Jobs