Skip to Main Content
Mama Mia's Italian Cuisine logo topMama Mia's Italian Cuisine logo scroll
  • (414)-475-0400
  • info@mamamiasmilwaukee.com
  • 8533 West Greenfield Avenue , West Allis
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • ORDER
  • EVENTS
  • CATERING
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • HOURS
  • Facebook pageYelp page
Mama Mia's Italian Cuisine logo topMama Mia's Italian Cuisine logo scroll
  • Facebook pageYelp page
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • ORDER
  • EVENTS
  • CATERING
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • HOURS

Our Menu

Main MenuKid's MenuParty Pans

CARRY-OUT and DINE-IN: MON TUE & THUR: 11am - 9 pm | FRI & SAT: 11am - 10 pm | SUNDAY: 11am - 8 pm

Appetizers

Our Famous Homemade Garlic Bread photo

Our Famous Homemade Garlic Bread

$3.99
$4.99
Made with 100% real Butter |

Mozzarella Marinara

$9.95
5 Large Mozzarella sticks hand-breaded in our Kitchen and served with Marinara sauce

Eggplant Strips

$9.99
Hand-breaded in our Kitchen and served with Marinara sauce

Breaded Mushrooms

$9.99
Hand-breaded in our Kitchen and served with Marinara sauce

Breaded Zucchini Strips

$9.99
Served with Ranch dressing

Combination Platter

$12.50
Mozz Sticks, Mushrooms & Zucchini, served with Marinara sauce

Chicken Tenderloin Strips

$9.99
BBQ, Honey Mustard, Ranch or Honey on request

Jalapeño Cream-Cheese Poppers

$9.99
served with Marinara sauce or homemade Raspberry sauce

Minestrone Soup

$3.99/Cup
$5.99/Bowl
$10.50/Quart
Homemade in our Kitchen

Salads

House Salad is served with iceberg & Romaine lettuce, Mozzarella cheese cubes, Pepperoni, tomatoes, and pepperoncini | Salad Dressings: Our House (Oil & Vinegar) | Homemade Ranch | Peppery Parmesan | French | 1000 Island | Bleu Cheese | Honey Mustard | Extra Sides (mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, pepperoncini) ea. $1.00 Caesar Salad is made with Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing and homemade Garlic Bread croutons

Dinner House photo

Dinner House

$3.99
Medium House photo

Medium House

$9.75
Serves 1-2 people, includes 1 garlic bread
Large House photo

Large House

$15.25
Serves up to 4 people, includes 2 garlic bread
Caesar Salad - side photo

Caesar Salad - side

$4.99
Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese, homemade croutons and Caesar dressing. Add a baked Chicken breast +$4.95 / anchovies +$2.50
Caesar Salad Entree photo

Caesar Salad Entree

$10.95
Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese, homemade croutons and Caesar dressing. Comes with one Garlic Bread. Comparable in size to our House Salad - Medium. Add a baked Chicken breast +$4.95 / anchovies +$2.50

Sandwiches

Mushrooms-Onion-Green Peppers-Marinara Sauce (free) | Mozzarella cheese - $1.00 | Add waffle fries - $1.95

Grilled Mozzarella Cheese on Garlic Bread photo

Grilled Mozzarella Cheese on Garlic Bread

$10.50
Our twist on an old favorite using grated mozzarella cheese on our homemade Garlic Bread and served with a cup of our house-made Meat Sauce for dipping. (You can request Marinara instead)

Meatballs on Garlic Bread

$12.50
Our hand rolled meatballs served in meatsauce on our Garlic Bread which has been sliced in half.

Sausage on Garlic Bread

$12.50
We start with a hand-formed sausage patty, bake it, and serve it up on our homemade Garlic Bread.

Following sandwiches served on toasted Gonnella bun (Similar to a Hoagie bun)

Italian Beef photo

Italian Beef

$12.50
Thinly shaved beef dipped in our special au jus and served on a Gonnella bun/similar to a hoagie bun. Giardiniera sauce on the side.

Sicilian Chicken

$11.50
Marinated, baked chicken breast, served on a Gonnella roll with marinara sauce and Mozzarella cheese

Chicken Parmesan

$12.50
Hand-breaded chicken breast that is deep fried and then topped with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Served on a Gonnella roll/similar to a Hoagie roll.

Pasta

Lunch 11am to 3pm / Dinner : 3pm to close | All entrees include one Garlic Bread

Pasta with Meatsauce or Marinara Sauce:

Mostaccioli

$10.25/Lunch
$13.50/Dinner
Lunch/Dinner $9.95/$12.95

Ravioli

$10.25/Lunch
$13.50/Dinner
Beef or cheese, or combo | Lunch/Dinner $9.95/$12.95
Fettucini Alfredo photo

Fettucini Alfredo

$12.99/Lunch
$16.99/Dinner
Made from scratch Lunch/Dinner $11.50 /14.50 | w/ sliced chicken breast +$4.95

Gluten Free Mostaccioli

$10.75/Lunch
$14.00/Dinner
a Gluten Free noodle served with MeatSauce or Marinara
Spaghetti photo

Spaghetti

$10.25/Lunch
$13.50/Dinner
Lunch/Dinner $9.95/$12.95

Pizza

(9 inch Mini available at lunch-time only) Made with Our Famous Thin-Crust - Small* 11" - Large 14" - Mini 8" (lunch only)|

Mozzarella Cheese Pizza

$8.25/+
Mini $8.25 | Small $12.45 | Large $16.75

Regular Toppings

$1.50/+
Mushrooms | Onions | Black Olives | Green Olives | Green Peppers | Diced Tomatoes | Italian Spices blend |Sliced Jalepeno | Mini $1.50 | Small $2.25 | Large $2.75

Premium Toppings

$1.75/+
Sausage | Pepperoni | Ground Beef | Anchovies | Pineapple | Canadian Bacon | Chopped Garlic | Pepperoncini | Extra cheese | Mini $1.75 | Small $2.50 | Large $3.50

"E.B.A."

$14.95/Mini
$21.45/Small
$27.95/Large
Everything But Anchovies” | $14.95 | $21.45 | $27.95 Actually a EBA is everything on the Garden, plus sausage, pepperoni, ground beef

"Garden"

$10.75/Mini
$16.45/Small
$20.95/Large
Mushrooms, onions, black olives, green peppers & diced tomatoes | $10.75 | $16.45 | $20.95

"Hawaiian"

$11.75/Mini
$14.25/Small
$19.10/Large
Canadian-style bacon & pineapple | $11.75 | $14.25 | $19.10

"Sicilian"

$10.20/MIni
$15.45/Small
$20.55/Large
Diced tomatoes, onions, fresh garlic, Italian spice blend & a splash of extra-virgin olive oil | $10.20 | $15.45 | $20.55

Gluten-Free 10” Crust ($3 extra)

$3.00
Topping prices correlate to small pizza

Margherita

$10.70/Mini
$15.95/Small
$20.95/Large
Fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh basil, Roma tomatoes, and a drizzle of Balsamic vinegar glaze

Lunch Entrees

Lunch 11am to 3pm / Dinner : 3pm to close | All entrees include one Garlic Bread

Lasagna photo

Lasagna

$10.75
Our famous lasagna features layers of pasta, meat sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

Spinach Lasagna

$10.75
A special twist on an old favorite features pasta sheets layered with marinara sauce, ricotta cheese, asiago cheeses and spinach. Very good, but quite different from our regular Lasagna.
Baked Pasta w/ Mozzarella Cheese photo

Baked Pasta w/ Mozzarella Cheese

$10.25
Penne/mostaccioli noodles with meatsauce, topped with Mozzarella cheese and oven baked.

Manicotti

$10.25
Ricotta cheese baked in pasta rolls with Marinara sauce, topped with Mozzarella cheese, then oven baked.

Chicken Parmesan

$14.50
The lunch portion features 1 chicken breast, hand-breaded and then deep-fried, topped with Marinara sauce, Mozzarella and Parmesean cheeses, served on a bed of pasta.

Eggplant Parmesan

$11.95
Hand breaded eggplant rounds that are deep fried and then topped with Marinara and oven melted mozzarella

Lunch Specials

Monday: Mini Pizza

$13.50
Up to 3 toppings and includes one Garlic Bread

Dinner Specials

Monday: Lasagna

(1 garlic bread with each Las.) Buy 1, Get the 2nd at half price

Monday: Family Night Pizza Special

$34.25
Large pizza with up to 3 toppings, 2 Garlic Breads & pitcher of soda or 1/2 carafe House wine + $7 | Dine in Only

Tuesday: All You Can Eat pasta

$13.50
Spaghetti or Penne / Marinara or Meat sauce. Served with one Garlic Bread | Dine in Only

Thursday: Pizza

Buy 1 and get the 2nd at half price

Friday:

Baked Fish Lemon Butter

$15.50
3 pieces of baked cod served with melted butter and lemon slices. | Side of coleslaw, a small side of Pasta with Marinara or MeatSauce, and one Garlic Bread

Baked Fish Sicilian

$15.50
3 pieces of baked cod topped with Marinara and Mozzarella cheese. | Side of cole slaw, small Pasta with either Marinara or MeatSauce, and one Garlic Bread.
Fish Fry photo

Fish Fry

$15.50
Over a half pound of beer-battered cod paired with fries, coleslaw, tartar sauce & one Garlic Bread

Dinner Entrees

Dinner served 3pm to close | All Entrees include one Garlic Bread

Lasagna photo

Lasagna

$15.25
One of our Signature Items. Layers of pasta sheets, our homemade MeatSauce, and Mozzarella cheese.
Spinach Lasagna photo

Spinach Lasagna

$15.25
A special twist on an old favorite features pasta sheets layered with Marinara sauce , ricotta cheese, asiago cheeses and spinach. Very good, but quite different from our regular Lasagna

Baked Pasta w/ Mozzarella Cheese

$14.75

Manicotti

$14.75
Ricotta cheese filled large pasta tubes topped with Marinara and oven melted Mozzarella
Chicken Parmesan (2 chicken breasts) photo

Chicken Parmesan (2 chicken breasts)

$20.95
The dinner portion features 2 chicken breasts, hand-breaded and then deep-fried, topped with marinara sauce, mozzarella and parmesan cheeses, served on a bed of pasta.

Eggplant Parmesan

$16.50

Sides

Pasta (2/3 Pint) with Sauce

$4.50
side of Spaghetti or Penne/Mostaccioli with Meat Sauce or Marinara

Meatball (1) Hand-Rolled

$3.25
Our meatballs are made in-house, by hand, using our Garlic Bread crumbs, cheese, spices and then oven-baked. The pre-baked weight is 4 oz

Italian Sausage Link

$4.25

Chicken Breast

$4.95
Marinated and oven-baked chicken breast

Anchovies

$2.50

French Fries

$1.95
Waffle-cut

Desserts

Tiramisu photo

Tiramisu

$6.95

Ultimate Chocolate Cake

$7.95
multiple layers of chocolate cake and chocolate frosting

Oreo Cheesecake

$7.95
Cannoli photo

Cannoli

$3.50

Ice Cream Scoop

$3.50
Spumoni or Vanilla

Limoncello Cheesecake

$7.25
A refreshing, Italian-inspired cheesecake made with sweet ricotta and cream cheese with luscious limoncello flavors and shortbread topping, Served with homemade Raspberry sauce

Sauces To Go

SIZE REFERENCES: Cup = 8oz | Pint = 16 oz (two Cups) | Quart = 32 oz (two Pints)

Cup MeatSauce

$3.50
8 ounces of our signature Homemade MeatSauce

Cup Marinara

$1.99
8 ounces of Marinara sauce

Cup Alfredo Sauce

$3.99
8 ounces of our homemade Alfredo sauce

Cup Melted Butter

$2.50

Pint MeatSauce

$7.50
16 ounces of our signature Homemade MeatSauce

Pint Marinara

$3.99
16 ounces of Marinara sauce

Pint Alfredo Sauce

$7.50
16 ounces of homemade Alfredo sauce

Pint Salad Dressing

$4.25

Pint Melted Butter

$5.99

Quart MeatSauce

$13.99
32 ounces of our signature Homemade Meatsauce

Quart Marinara

$7.99
32 ounces of Marinara sauce

Quart Alfredo Sauce

$13.75

Quart Salad Dressing

$8.50

Soup

We have Homemade Minestrone every day. Made with ditalini noodles, beef, kidney beans, carrots, celery. A classic Italian soup

Minestrone

$3.99/Cup
$5.99/Bowl
$10.50/Quart
Homemade in our Kitchen

MISCELLANEOUS ITEMS

Miscellaneous Items

Plate

9" foam plate

Napkin

Parmesan Packet

Red Pepper Flakes packet

Individual Silverware Pack

$0.20
fork, knife, spoon set up for individual orders

Kid's Menu Dishes

Pasta dishes made with your choice of: Homemade Meat Sauce | Marinara Sauce

Mostaccioli (Penne) with Garlic Bread

$7.00
with MeatSauce or Marinara

Ravioli (Beef or Cheese) with Garlic Bread

$7.00
with Marinara or MeatSauce

Spaghetti with Garlic Bread

$7.00
with Marinara or MeatSauce

Fettuccini Alfredo with Garlic Bread

$7.00

Fettucini Alfredo w/ 1/2 Chicken Breast

$8.99
Fettucini Alfredo with 1/2 baked chicken breast with Garlic Bread

Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Mozzarella Cheese

$7.00
Add Fries for $1.50

Chicken Fingers with Waffle-Cut Fries

$7.00

Party Pans can be ordered in small and large sizes. Garlic Bread served with pasta dishes; no Garlic Bread is served with Salad choices. Party pans do not come with serving utensils {Spatula, Tongs, Serving Spoon}. But they can be added for a small price. (We do not include the cost of utensils into party pans because many customers do not need them.)

Party Pan Options

Large: Serves 16 - 20, includes 10 Garlic Bread | Small: Serves 8 - 10, includes 6 Garlic Bread

Lasagna

$84.95/small
$159.95/large
Layers of noodles and MeatSauce topped with oven-melted Mozzarella cheese. This is a Mama Mia signature dish!

Spinach Lasagna

$84.95/small
$159.95/large
A special twist on a favorite! Pasta sheets layered with Marinara sauce, Ricotta and Asiago cheese and Spinach

Ravioli

$84.95/small
$135.95/large
Beef, Cheese or Combination of both. Can be served with Homemade MeatSauce or Marinara.

Fettucini Alfredo

$84.95/small
$159.95/large
Homemade Fettucini made in house with Butter, Cream, Garlic, Cheese. (No flour is used when making the Alfredo sauce)

Spaghetti

$74.95/small
$129.95/large
Spaghetti served with either Marinara or MeatSauce

Mostacciolli

$74.95/small
$129.95/large
Penne / Mostaccioli pasta served with Homemade MeatSauce or Marinara

Chicken Parmesan

$119.95/small
$229.95/large
Includes a bed of pasta ~ Large (20 chicken breasts) | Small (10 chicken breasts)

Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo

$104.95/small
$189.95/large
Served with oven-baked diced chicken breasts: 4 for the small and 8 for the large.

Baked Pasta

$79.95/Small
$144.95/Large
Mostaccioli / penne noodles with Marinara or Homemade MeatSauce and topped with Mozzarella cheese and oven baked.

Italian Salad

$29.95/small
$55.95/large
Does NOT include garlic bread ~ Large (serves 30 people) | Small (serves 15 people). Served with a mix of Romaine /Iceberg. Diced mozzarella and tomatoes, Pepperoni, and Pepperoncini. Comes with House Italian salad dressing. Other salad dressing available on request.

Garlic Bread

$34.99
10-Pack of Garlic Bread. You save by buying in quantity.

Spatula

$1.50
Spatula for serving Lasagna

Tongs

$1.50
Tongs for serving Garlic Bread, Salad

Serving Spoon Large

$1.50
Good for serving Ravioli, Fettucini, etc

Individual Utensil Pack

$0.20
wrapped packet of knife/fork/spoon for party pan quantities
  • Order
  • Catering
  • Jobs